10 Can’t-Miss Historical Gems in and Around Fort Myers Beach, According to Locals
Step back in time with 10 historical gems in Fort Myers and beyond: lighthouses, museums, ancient mounds, and stories locals love to share.
Every vacation, from Colorado and Montana to North Carolina and Florida, becomes more interesting when you explore the historical gems each destination has to offer. Learning about the history and culture of a place gives you fresh eyes to experience it fully.
Did you pick Fort Myers Beach or the surrounding area as your next vacation destination? Lucky you! If you’re a history buff or simply like to add a touch of history to your itinerary, you’ll find incredible attractions in and around town to make your visit even more special.
Here’s a little glimpse to spark your curiosity:
River District, Downtown Fort Myers: Historic architecture, markers, shops, and dining in a lively old Florida setting.
Burroughs Home: Early 20th-century riverside home with entertaining guided tours.
Edison and Ford Winter Estates: Homes, museum, inventions, vintage cars, and lush gardens of two American icons.
Mound House, Fort Myers Beach: Archaeological site with Calusa artifacts and exhibits on early settlers.
Koreshan State Park, Estero: Preserves the story and lifestyle of the Koreshan Unity religious commune.
Mound Key, Estero Bay: Ancient Calusa ceremonial center, accessible only by boat, with shell mounds and trails.
Sanibel Lighthouse: Historic 1884 lighthouse, panoramic Gulf and bay views, and sunrise vistas.
Randell Research Center, Pine Island: Archaeological site with tours and exhibits on the Calusa tribe’s way of life.
Pine Island Museum (Museum of the Islands): Local history from Calusa tools to settler life, in a cozy setting.
Chapel by the Sea Cemetery, Captiva: Graves of early settlers, including William Herbert Binder and Ann Brainerd’s touching tombstone.
At Sun Palace Vacations, we offer stunning vacation homes in Fort Myers Beach. Whether you’re looking for a beachfront escape or a cozy retreat, we have the perfect place for you. We consider ourselves Fort Myers Beach experts, and from the best shopping spots and top-notch restaurants to a comprehensive guide on fishing and hunting in the area, we’ve got you covered in our blog.
In this post, I’ve rounded up ten historical gems in and around Fort Myers Beach, highly recommended by locals, to quench your appetite for knowledge and add both interesting facts and fun to your trip. And the cherry on top? Local tips that make your experience feel authentic and complete.
Ready? Let’s dive in!
A Quick Look Back at Fort Myers Beach History
2,000 years ago: The Calusa Indians built impressive shell mounds along Estero Island’s bayside.
Spanish & British rule: Control of the area shifted between European powers before American settlers arrived in the mid-1800s.
1920s boom: Growth took off after a toll bridge connected Fort Myers Beach to the mainland, turning it into a holiday hotspot.
1995 incorporation: The town was officially incorporated and continues to balance development with preserving its historic charm.
History Hotspots in and Around Fort Myers Beach
1. River District in Downtown Fort Myers
Beautifully preserved old Florida architecture.
The River District in Downtown Fort Myers is a vibrant area that keeps its historic charm intact. With beautifully preserved old Florida architecture, the district offers a delightful mix of history and modern amenities. Strolling through the streets, you can soak up the old-world ambiance while enjoying contemporary shops, restaurants, and entertainment options.
History buffs will love the architectural details and historical markers scattered throughout the district. It’s a fantastic spot to appreciate the blend of past and present, making it a lively and educational part of any Fort Myers visit.
2. Burroughs Home
Historic house on the river.
The Burroughs Home, located in downtown Fort Myers, is a charming historic house on the river. The guided tours are known for being both informative and entertaining, offering a detailed look at the life and times of the Burroughs family and early 20th-century Fort Myers.
You’ll love the well-preserved home and the engaging stories shared by the guides. The beautiful riverside setting adds to the appeal, making it a pleasant and educational stop for history enthusiasts. It’s a great way to immerse yourself in the local history of Fort Myers.
3. Edison and Ford Winter Estates
Winter homes of Thomas Edison and Henry Ford, & More.
The Edison and Ford Winter Estates on McGregor Boulevard are a must-see for anyone interested in American innovation and history. These beautifully maintained grounds feature the winter homes of Thomas Edison and Henry Ford, along with a museum showcasing their numerous inventions and vintage cars.
Visitors often praise the picturesque setting, perfect for leisurely strolls and photo ops. The blend of technological history and stunning gardens makes this estate a favorite for both casual tourists and history buffs.
👍 Local Tip
Ford’s Garage is a fun, automotive-themed restaurant perfect for grabbing a bite after exploring the Edison and Ford Winter Estates. The restaurant is decked out with vintage car memorabilia and even features a replica of a 1920s service station.
4. Mound House
A significant historical site remembering the indigenous Calusa people.
The Mound House on Fort Myers Beach offers a fascinating look at the area’s history, from ancient times to more recent events. This site includes exhibits on the indigenous Calusa people and the early settlers of the region. Despite some areas being damaged, it remains a significant historical site.
For those interested in a broad spectrum of history, the Mound House provides a little something for everyone. The mix of ancient artifacts and historical displays makes it an engaging destination. Plus, the scenic location on Fort Myers Beach adds to its appeal.
5. Koreshan State Park
Quirky historical site preserving the story and lifestyle of the Koreshan settlers.
This one is really a top rec. Koreshan State Park in Estero preserves the fascinating story of the Koreshan Unity, a religious commune from the late 19th century. Walking through the park feels like stepping back in time, with well-preserved buildings and artifacts that illustrate the unique beliefs and lifestyle of the Koreshan settlers.
If you’re interested in quirky historical sites, this park is a must-visit. The serene environment and informative displays make it an enjoyable and educational outing.
6. Mound Key
An archaeological site believed to be the ceremonial center of the ancient Calusa tribe.
Mound Key, an archaeological site in Estero Bay, is believed to be the ceremonial center of the ancient Calusa tribe. This island, accessible only by boat, showcases impressive shell mounds that tell the story of a once-thriving community. You can hike through the trails and imagine what life was like for the Calusa people.
History enthusiasts will appreciate the chance to explore such a significant and undisturbed site. The combination of natural beauty and historical significance makes Mound Key a unique glimpse into Florida’s pre-colonial past.
7. Sanibel Lighthouse
A symbol of resilience and a place for epic views and sunrises.
The Sanibel Lighthouse stands as a resilient symbol of the island’s history. While previous hurricanes washed away some of the older buildings, the lighthouse itself remains a cherished landmark. It’s a great spot for taking in the scenic views and snapping some photos.
Speaking of scenic views, the lighthouse is not just appreciated for its historical significance, but also for the beautiful surroundings. The lighthouse sits right where the Gulf meets San Carlos Bay, so the views are wide open and stunning. From the grounds, you’ll see sweeping panoramas of turquoise water, fishing boats heading in and out, and some of the best sunrise vistas on the island since it faces east.
8. Randell Research Center on Pine Island
Archaeological gem offering in-depth information about the Calusa tribe.
The Randell Research Center on Pine Island is an archaeological gem that delves into the rich history of the Calusa tribe. This site offers a unique opportunity to explore the remnants of one of Florida’s most significant indigenous cultures. The guided tours are a highlight, providing in-depth information about the Calusa’s way of life, their sophisticated canal systems, and shell mounds.
For history buffs, the center is a treasure trove of artifacts and exhibits that paint a vivid picture of the past. The peaceful surroundings and well-preserved sites make it a wonderful day trip, offering both educational value and a serene escape into nature.
9. Pine Island Museum
A quaint museum dedicated to the history of Pine Island.
Also known as the Museum of the Islands, the Pine Island Museum is a quaint spot dedicated to the history of Pine Island. It offers a variety of exhibits on the local history, from the Calusa tribe to the early settlers and the island’s development over the years.
History buffs will find the museum’s collection both comprehensive and charming. Some of the highlights include a collection of pottery, shell tools, and a mural inspired by 19th-century archaeologist Frank Cushing. It’s a small but rich repository of local history, making it a delightful stop for those looking to delve deeper into the area’s past. The museum’s intimate setting adds to its charm.
10. Chapel by the Sea Cemetery in Captiva
Graves of Captiva’s earliest homesteaders.
The tiny cemetery near Chapel by the Sea in Captiva is a serene and historic spot worth visiting. This charming little cemetery offers a peaceful place to reflect and appreciate the history of the island’s residents.
While visiting this historical gem, you’ll see graves of Captiva’s earliest homesteaders, including William Herbert Binder, who was famously shipwrecked and later settled here in 1888. Another highlight is the touching tombstone of Ann Brainerd, a four-year-old buried on land she purchased herself, known today as “her land,” where visitors still leave shells as a tribute.
Extra History Tips to Enjoy Your Visit to Fort Myers Beach and Beyond
🚶Historical Walking Tours in Fort Myers
There are several historical walking tours available in Fort Myers, run by knowledgeable guides who can provide a wealth of information about the area.
One highly recommended option is the True Tours of Downtown Fort Myers. These tours are praised for their engaging and informative nature, making them a fantastic way to explore the city’s history.
📚 Good Reads
For those who want to dive deeper into the history of Fort Myers and Southwest Florida, here are some great reads:
- “Hidden History of Fort Myers” by Cynthia Williams: A concise and factual book offering a quick dive into the area’s history.
- “A Land Remembered” by Patrick Smith: A fictional narrative rich in local and state history, providing a captivating read.
- “The Sea Shell Islands”: A History of Sanibel and Captiva” by Elinore M. Dormer: An in-depth look at the history of Sanibel and Captiva Islands.
Wondering Where to Stay in Fort Myers Beach
To experience the highest quality in amenities, decor, and cleanliness, book your stay with Sun Palace Vacations. We guarantee you’ll have the most enjoyable and relaxing vacation ever!